Packaging
In association with Mondi Packaging
Future of smart packaging PDF Print E-mail
Written by Pira International, 2007   

Intelligent and smart packaging can benefit many end-use sectors, but none more so than food, drinks, pharmaceuticals and cosmetics. Pira International takes a closer look. 

The global food sector is the main market for smart packaging, not just because of its size but also because active and intelligent packaging can help to meet consumer demand for improved quality and safety of food products, as well as more convenience. Among end-use sectors, the biggest sales of active and intelligent packaging will continue to be generated by the global food market.

The food and drink market will be the fastest-growing outlet for sales of intelligent packaging. This will be mainly because of increased demand for diagnostic packaging in response to consumer desires for more information about freshness of foods, and also because of the need for track-and-trace systems. Intelligent packaging sales in this sector are expected to rise by more than fivefold to over $250 million (€199 million) between 2005 and the end of the decade.

Rising sales of oxygen scavengers, and to a lesser extent UV blockers, will be helped by the continued rapid rise of PET as a bottling material. The growing problem of counterfeiting, which electronic tracking systems can help to combat, will be a strong impetus behind sales of RFID components in the pharmaceutical, cosmetics and apparel markets.

Alcohol and beverages

This sector saw the first applications of active packaging methods, in some cases before modern packaging technologies evolved. Hence in many alcohol markets, glass has retained its centuries-old dominance.

Glass is a highly effective barrier against oxygen and - when coloured - light, which together are the major contributors to the deterioration of packaged drinks.

In the non-alcohol sector, however, glass has been losing ground to rival materials, although remains popular in some local soft drink segments. In the milk market, for example, glass bottles were first replaced by paper cartons with coated inlays, and now increasingly by plastic containers.

Glass, and to a lesser extent metal, are now under attack from plastic materials - in particular polyethylene terephthalate (PET) - across a broad range of both non-alcohol and alcohol sectors. Changes in lifestyles and consumer consumption patterns have been a major impetus behind a switch to plastics.

The poor oxygen and light barrier properties of plastics has provided opportunities for suppliers of active packaging components to improve performance. For example, the amount of oxygen entering a PET bottle without an oxygen scavenger can be six to eight times higher, in the first 60-100 days of the shelf-life of its contents, than in one with a scavenger integrated into polymer.

Alcohol

Arguably the oldest form of active packaging has been the use of wooden barrels to help continue the fermentation and flavouring of alcohols during their storage, in particular spirits such as whisky and brandy, and to a lesser extent wines.

As a packaging application, the barrels have releasing and absorbing capabilities to change and improve the organoleptic qualities of the drink. European Union regulators have decided that these traditional storage methods should be considered part of the manufacturing process rather than as a packaging system.

The traditional wine bottles were designed for the continuation of fermentation and flavouring. Corks considerably reduce oxygen permeability but do not completely halt it. Wine experts believe the cork helps the continued fermentation of fine wines by admitting small amounts of oxygen into the bottle. Recently this process has been reversed by the introduction of plastic corks and screwtops, mainly in response to the contamination of corks, which can spoil 1-5 per cent of wines.

Alcohol remains the principal supporter of glass packaging in many parts of the world, not only because of its capacity to keep out oxygen, but also because it has the image of a premium packaging material, especially in North America and Europe.

However, in some regions PET bottles have virtually taken over the market, especially in the beer segment. Unlike in the established markets of industrialised countries, glass in many emerging economies has a reputation for poor quality and lack of cleanliness, owing to the way glass bottles were reused and not washed properly by bottlers in the past.

Image
Table 1. Estimated sales of beer bottles with oxygen scavenger properties by region 2001-05.
In the Russian beer market, for example, there has been a massive switch to PET bottles. In 2005, Russia accounted for 70 per cent of Eastern European sales of beer bottles with oxygen scavengers, and 56 per cent of the global total. Glass is held in similarly low esteem in China, where PET has been making inroads.

In these relatively new markets for PET bottles, the material has tended to be applied as a single-layer barrier in which oxygen scavengers have been incorporated to prevent quick degradation of the alcohol. Higher grade PET - often still requiring active packaging components - has begun to gain comparatively big shares of certain alcohol markets in North America and to a lesser extent Europe. PET now accounts for 20 per cent by volume of spirits packaged in the US.

Soft drinks

The fast growth of carbonated soft drinks in many parts of the world has been driven by PET. Its weight, stackability and unbreakability have made soft drinks much easier and cheaper to distribute.

Unlike with alcoholic drinks, particularly beer, PET bottles for carbonated soft drinks do not typically require oxygen scavengers because they often have an interior coating. The main purpose of this coating is to keep in the carbon dioxide, but it also acts as a barrier to permeation of oxygen.

There is, by contrast, a relatively big demand for oxygen scavengers in plastic bottles for non-carbonated drinks such as juices, sports and functional drinks, the ingredients of which can be sensitive to oxygen.

There is an increasing demand in areas such as North America for antimicrobial components in PET and other plastic bottles for water. This is mainly because the water is packaged in larger bottles than in other regions, such as Europe, which can precipitate the accumulation of bacteria.

Pharmaceutical and healthcare

Traditionally, the main requirements from packaging for pharmaceuticals, diagnostic medicines and other healthcare products were, besides the provision of basic identification and safety data, protection against damage and quick degradation. Recently these needs have been extended to safeguard against tampering, theft and counterfeiting, helping with brand protection.

In some areas of the world, including Western Europe, pharmaceutical companies are looking for active and intelligent packaging solutions to the problem of parallel trading. This is a practice under which distributors or traders buy branded pharmaceuticals in a country with low drug prices and sell them in another with higher prices.

Smart packaging is also seen as having the potential to improve patients' compliance with dosage regimes. It could even provide a means for self-diagnosis of some conditions.

Image
Table 2. Value and growth (%) of intelligent retail packaging in the pharmaceutical and healthcare sector 2001-10 ($ million).
Many medicines, such as anti-infectives and vaccines, need to be kept in low temperatures from the time they leave the manufacturing plant through to their administering to the patient. The development of time-temperature indicators (TTIs) on packaging materials has helped detect changes in temperature during transit, which could endanger the quality of the drug. There are also systems for alerting producers, distributors, wholesalers and retailers, as well as healthcare providers, to changes in levels of humidity and incidents of shock to products during transit.

RFID and other electronic systems with data memories and transmission capabilities are increasingly being employed by pharmaceutical companies and distributors to track and trace medical products through the supply chain. In the US, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has been working on regulations to make such systems obligatory.

Counterfeiting

Counterfeiting of pharmaceuticals has become a widespread problem. The World Health Organization (WHO) estimated that 7 per cent of all drugs sold worldwide are fakes, which generate sales of around $30 billion (€25.2 billion) annually.

In some parts of the developing world and emerging markets, counterfeiting is particularly rampant. In Pakistan and Nigeria, for example, around half of pharmaceuticals are estimated to be bogus. In China and Russia, counterfeits account for a large proportion of the sale of certain brands of medicines. In India, counterfeit medicines are estimated to make up as much as 20 per cent of the country's drugs market. The Indian government is taking the rise in fake medicines so seriously that it has even proposed introducing the death penalty for criminals found guilty of counterfeiting medicines.

In North America and Western Europe, counterfeits comprise as much as 5 per cent of sales, which has prompted regulators to consider steps to protect the population. The FDA has been drawing up a series of proposed measures, which could include the use of RFID systems to authenticate medicines.

The agency issued a warning in May 2005 about the sale in the US of counterfeit versions of leading drugs such as the anti-cholesterol treatment Lipitor, the erectile dysfunctional drug Viagra, and the anti-osteoporosis medication Evista. Analysis of the drugs showed they contained no active ingredients.

Intelligent packaging technologies could help to combat counterfeiting by providing hidden components in the packaging materials, which, with the help of scanners, can be identified as containing the genuine product.

Parallel trading could also be curbed by similar initiatives. Although some parallel traders repackage branded drugs, they make no attempts to market them as other than the original branded medicines. So for pharmaceutical companies the practice can present a major challenge, because in most cases parallel trading is legal. The drug manufacturers may have to persuade distributors and retailers to co-operate in any moves to thwart it.

Much research and development work is being done on intelligent packaging systems that can help patients to take their medicines at the frequency and quantities prescribed. Some have already been commercialised. In the US, the costs of non-compliance in the consumption of medicines is calculated to be as much as $100 billion, when the expense of hospitalisations is taken into account. Around 8 per cent of these extra costs are thought to fall on the drugs industry itself.

Intelligent packaging can contribute to the effectiveness of clinical trials of new medicines by helping to ensure compliance by participants. MeadWestvaco Healthcare Packaging of the US has recently introduced Cerepak, which is initially being employed in clinical trials. Developed in co-operation with Cypac of Sweden, it comprises a blister structure with individual compartments for each pill and incorporates a microprocessor and printed conductive ink. The electronic components enable it to record data on the time when a pill is taken, on side-effects through a reusable questionnaire pad, and to provide an audible reminder if necessary.

The information from the package can be downloaded onto a PC so that the level of the patient's compliance can be checked by a doctor, while it also provides useful clinical trial data.

Cypac, which specialises in the development of electronic systems such as embedded microcomputers in paper packaging materials, is testing methods for integrating blood biosensors in paperboard packaging. These would help the self-diagnosis of excess sugar levels in diabetes patients, and levels of cholesterol in people with cardiovascular problems.

Image
Table 3. Estimates of revenue loss by sector in Europe owing to counterfeiting 1998 (€ million).
The need for protection against counterfeiting, improvements in tracking and tracing of medicines through the supply chain and the introduction of innovations such as dosage compliance systems on packaging will lead to a fivefold increase in sales of intelligent packaging in pharmaceuticals and healthcare between 2005 and 2010.

Cosmetics and toiletries

Packaging of cosmetics and toiletries has similar needs to that of pharmaceuticals. Because of their strong brand value, many cosmetics, particularly perfumes, are counterfeited. Cosmetics and toiletries are also subject to tampering. Some are heat-sensitive, so require a certain amount of temperature control when stored. Certain types of cosmetics are also vulnerable to oxygen and other gases, and to the effects of light. In some hot climates they are even susceptible to microbes.

Counterfeit products are estimated to account for around 10 per cent of the global cosmetics and toiletries market. As with pharmaceuticals, fake cosmetics have the largest proportion of sales in developing countries, particularly in Asia. Nonetheless, even in Western Europe bogus cosmetics are thought to have a share of 7 per cent of the market.

A report by the Centre for Economics and Business Research (CEBR) for the Global Anti- Counterfeiting Group (GACC), representing leading multinational companies, has estimated that counterfeiting in the EU has cut revenues from perfumes and cosmetics by €3 billion annually. The profits of perfume and cosmetic companies were reduced by €555 million by the activities of counterfeiters in the EU alone.

Along with the pharmaceuticals sector, the cosmetics industry has been one of biggest spenders on security measures to protect itself against counterfeiters. Some of these initiatives have involved adopting innovations in intelligent packaging such as electronic tagging, digital watermarks, electromagnetic components and thermochromic inks. Expenditure on intelligent packaging within the cosmetics and toiletries sector is predicted to grow by 75 per cent to $64 million between 2005 and 2010.

Image
Table 4. Value and growth (%) of intelligent retail packaging in cosmetic and toiletries 2001-10 ($ million).
Cosmetic and toiletries manufacturers also use active packaging systems to help promote their products and reinforce brand image. Packaging materials can release aromas externally so that consumers experience a pleasant smell from the product before they buy it. Aromas can also be encapsulated in plastic lids, closures and in flexible packaging materials. These are released into the contents of the package but also into the air when the package is opened to raise the acceptability of the product to the consumer.

Other sectors on the move

Apparel Fabrics provide a small outlet for oxygen scavengers as an aid to the preservation of natural fibres in storage and transit. However, the sector has the potential to be a significant market for intelligent packaging systems, particularly because of increasing pressure on clothing retailers to improve the efficiency of their supply chains.

In Europe, the fast fashion segment of the clothing market, which responds rapidly to trends determined by catwalk shows, increased by almost half between 2001 and 2005. The Spanish retail chain Zara can now design, manufacture and have a piece of clothing on its shelves within 15 days. The speed of its distribution is helped by an IT infrastructure using intelligent labelling systems along its supply chain.

The UK retail chain Marks & Spencer is extending an RFID trial from nine to 53 stores from spring 2006. This is to improve the availability of clothing with complex sizing systems, such as bras and suits. The test with passive RFID tags was started in 2004, with the chip contained within throwaway paper labels. During the next phase the chip will be integrated into the existing paper barcode label and will have the words "Intelligent Label for stock control use". The tags are being trialled to see how much they help Marks & Spencer check deliveries and count stock in stores and depots.

Clothes manufacturers and retailers are looking for assistance from intelligent packaging technologies like RFID to combat counterfeiting, which increased swiftly in reaction to the popularity of designer label clothes, which are comparatively easy to emulate.

For the designers and manufacturers there is the additional concern that counterfeiting has become so prevalent that a large proportion of consumers now accept that they could be buying fake items. By the late 1990s, counterfeit clothes and footwear had reached over 3 per cent of total sales in the European market, equivalent of a loss of revenue of €7.6 billion annually, according to a report by Centre for Economics and Business Research.

Sales of intelligent packaging in the apparel market are expected to more than double to $55 million between 2005 and 2010. Although EAS and to a lesser extent EMID are employed as anti-theft devices at the item level, much of the increase is likely to come from increased use of RFID in the textiles supply chain and as an aid to more efficient stocking within stores.

Music, videos and software

The music, audiovisual and software industries have been trying to find ways of using intelligent packaging to fight piracy and counterfeiting. Illegal music sales are worth €4 billion globally, or one-eighth of the value of the worldwide music market. In the five years to 2005, the number of pirated discs has doubled to more than one billion, equivalent to one in three of all music CDs, according to the International Federation for the Phonographic Industry (IFPI).

A number of components on packaging of CDs, DVDs and videos, including RFID and other electronic items, have been tested to make the detection of pirated versions easier. However, one difficulty has been expense.

Among the cheaper methods has been digital watermarking, which is an image, digital signal or pattern that is embedded into the packaging. They can be like logos so that they are visually recognisable, or can carry covert serial numbers to verify authenticity. CDs, DVDs and videos are also fitted with anti-theft devices by retailers because they are among the most frequently stolen items.

Besides combating criminality, RFID is also being used in stores to help shoppers find the recorded music and films they want. UK retailer Tesco has been trialling RFID tags on DVDs as a search aid for its customers.

Sales of intelligent packaging for the audiovisual and software sectors will rise by 78 per cent between 2005 and 2010, driven largely by measures to combat piracy. But the growth will be slower than in the previous five years, partly due to the rise in online downloading of music, which is slowing demand for CDs.

Electronics

The electronics sector is a major outlet for various active packaging systems for protecting electronic equipment from moisture during storage and transit, particularly in humid and tropical areas. Moisture or condensation can cause irreversible damage to highly sensitive electronic goods.

The packaging techniques for safeguarding the equipment include desiccants, corrosive gas scavenging bags, vapour-phase corrosion inhibitors (VCIs) and moisture-vapour barrier systems. Their level of application depends on costs, effectiveness and practicability. The use of films with moisture-absorbing components, such as VCIs, has been eliminating the need for desiccant sachets.

Another threat to electronic equipment in transit is electro-static discharge (ESD). In the whole US electronics sector, ESD is estimated to be causing annual damage of as much as $15 billion. Carbon black-based compounds in packaging materials have been the main components for protection against ESD, but these active substances have been meeting new competition from conductive polymers like polyaniline. They have the advantage of not requiring the addition of fillers to be made conductive. Unlike carbon, black polyaniline can be used with transparent and coloured films. Its level of conductivity is also easier to control.

Intelligent packaging sales in the electronics market will more than double to just under $20 million between 2005 and 2010, with the growth rate accelerating towards the end of the decade, particularly in Asia

Takeaways

  • Food is the main worldwide market for smart packaging, where active and intelligent packaging helps to meet consumer demands for improved quality and safety. This will continue to be the case.
  • The growing problem of counterfeiting is boosting sales of RFID components in the pharmaceutical, cosmetics and apparel markets.
  • Glass, with its high oxygen and light barrier properties, retains its dominance for alcoholic drinks, but is losing ground to PET bottles for soft drinks. This is creating opportunities for suppliers of smart packaging components, required to compensate for PET's poor barrier properties.
  • Smart packaging sees a variety of uses in the pharmaceuticals sector - protecting against counterfeit, parallel trading, damage and degradation, as well as improving patient compliance.
  • In the cosmetics and toiletries market, applications include anti-counterfeiting, anti-tamper, temperature-control and gas scavenging.
  • Cosmetics and pharmaceuticals companies are among the biggest spenders on anti-counterfeit technology.
  • For apparel, there is some demand for oxygen scavenging technologies for textiles, but smart technology application is mainly in supply chain improvements, where RFID is playing a growing role.
  • The audiovisual industries continue to find new application for intelligent packaging to protect product against piracy and counterfeiting, which is a huge problem in this sector. RFID is also being used to improve inventory efficiency here.
  • Electronics is a major market for active packaging systems that protect against moisture, including gas-scavengers, VCIs and moisture-vapour barrier systems.

This article contains research from the report The Future of Smart Packaging, published recently by Pira. To find out more, or to order a copy, contact: Mr Rav Lall, Tel: +44 (0)1372 802271, Email: This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
 
< Prev   Next >